from Column 13

Insights  ›  The house view

AI Voice Agents and Printed Booklets Belong in the Same Plan.

The tooling debate is a false choice. The right instrument depends on the company, not the year it was invented.

By Alex Benavides · July 14, 2026

There is a tell in most consulting pitches: the firm sells the tool it happens to own.

If it is an AI shop, your problem needs AI. If it is a change-management shop with a deck full of frameworks, your problem needs the framework. The instrument was chosen before anyone looked at you.

We think that is backwards. The right tool depends on the company and the moment, not the year the tool was invented. In practice that means we will put an AI voice agent and a printed booklet in the same plan without blinking, because they answer different questions.

Take both ends seriously

We advise a YC-founded AI voice-agent startup, so this is not a firm that is nervous about the new thing. A voice agent that can handle intake, scheduling, or a first-tier question at two in the morning without a human is genuinely transformative for the right workflow. It scales, it is consistent, it never has a bad day. Pointed at the wrong workflow, it is an expensive way to frustrate people who needed a person.

Now the other end. A hospital has a workforce that is largely not at a desk: nurses, techs, transport, environmental services, people on their feet and on a shift who will never open the all-staff email you spent a week crafting. For that audience a tactile one-page reference clipped to a badge or posted in the break room outperforms every digital channel you own, because it meets them where their hands and eyes actually are. That is not a nostalgic choice. It is the effective one.

The newest instrument is not the best one. The right one is.

It is an engineering question, not a values one

The mistake is treating this as a question about identity, whether you are a modern company or an old-fashioned one, when it is a question about fit. Who is the audience, what is the moment, what actually lands? Sometimes the answer is a model running inference in the cloud. Sometimes it is card stock. Usually, in a real change effort, it is both, aimed at different people for different reasons.

We will tell you when the expensive new thing is the wrong answer, and we will tell you when the cheap old thing is beneath you and you should stop clinging to it. What we will not do is let the tool pick the problem.

Arguments, by email

Get the next one.

New pieces when they're published. No tips lists, no newsletter about the newsletter, and nothing else in your inbox.

Thirty minutes. No pitch.

Tell us what's happening. We'll tell you what we'd do about it, including when the honest answer is that you don't need us.